Barbie Bus Politics

1 03 2015

The Labour Party faced ridicule recently when their Women to Women campaign was launched in a pink bus, prompting comedian John Oliver to suggest that they were engaging with women in the same way as toymaker Mattel engages with 8 year old girls.

Gloria De Piero, who probably thought she was trading the puerile soundbites of GMTV for the serious world of politics when she was elected MP for Ashfield at the 2010 election, was instead forced to stumble through an interview while trying to find a different word than pink for the obviously pink bus parked behind her. Harriet Harman chose to call it cerise but whatever the shade of pink it was a strange choice for a party who have vocally supported the PinkStink campaign and one which was always likely to be seen as patronising.

What was more alarming than the colour of the bus was how the Labour Party described the campaign itself. Lucy Powell, MP for Manchester Central, demonstrated just what they really thought about women when she suggested that they wanted, “to have a conversation about the kitchen table and around the kitchen table rather than having an economy that just reaches the boardroom table.” That’s right. They are coming to talk to you where you are; in the kitchen not the boardroom!

I thought that the opprobrium rightly heaped upon “The Woman Who Made Up Her Mind” video, released on behalf of the Better Together campaign which implied that women can’t think of big things when they have housework to do, would have taught Labour a lesson, but apparently not. And being patronising to women isn’t a Labour only issue. At a recent prestigious fundraising events held by the Conservatives one of the prizes was a shoe-shopping trip with Teresa May!

And anyway, with the manifesto already written this is not listening to women. It is merely talking at women.

But is there a need for a campaign for women at all? Does it really help to lump all women together in a homogenous mass of pink-loving, lovely, ladyness?

I am involved in many organisations which actively campaign to increase the recognition of the achievements of women and to promote greater participation of women across all aspects of society from shop floor to boardroom. During the debate on Scottish Independence I was active in writing articles, knocking on doors, giving out leaflets and generally campaigning. Yet it never occurred to me to join Women for Independence. The issues that occupied me, and millions of Scots on both sides of the debate, were those of social justice. Issues that affect both men and women. I am very unlikely to share the same views as any of the women the Daily Mail has called Cameron’s Cuties just because we both have ovaries. And young women starting out in work, looking for their first home, worried about repaying student loans, worried about getting a job have much more in common with young men of a similar age than they have with my retired and comfortably off mother. 51% of the population are women. Women are the average voter and not a niche, special interest group that have a narrow range of interests. Yes, there are issues that effect women in particular, like domestic violence being perpetrated largely by men against women, and the disadvantageous effects of the recent changes in the benefits system but issues like childcare directly affects mothers and those in traditional families, not all women.

There is a problem to be solved, though. One of engagement. At the 2010 election only 39% of young women bothered to vote. In total over 9m women didn’t exercise their right to vote. And, if you don’t talk about women then the debate becomes male dominated. Why? Because women aren’t IN politics. Women make up less than 22% of MP’s and less than 20% of cabinet posts are held by women…. and I actually heard Shirley Williams interviewed on Radio 4 this week saying that she thought her mother, Vera Brittain, would be proud of the progress women have made in politics.

To engage women we have to demonstrate that politics is not a man-only activity. This will not be achieved by driving a pink van through towns and villages. Far better would be for politicians to do their jobs and tackle issues such as equal pay. They could ensure that women are treated fairly in the workplace. If the Labour party really wanted to do something for women it could ensure that North Lanarkshire Council, which it runs and has run for generations, settles the 3,000 cases brought by women against it under equal pay legislation.

This “stop me an buy one” approach, with politicians arriving to a fanfare then leaving again like well-dressed ice-cream sellers, will not work.



One response

1 03 2015

GREAT RANT Karen – could not agree more, well said!

Leave a Reply to janekenyon Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: